LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES (LLCs)
Evaluating an LLC & Selecting a Tax Election
Entity structure, tax elections and planning for owners of single-member and multi-member LLCs throughout California.
An LLC is a legal structure, not a tax strategy.
The same LLC can be taxed as a sole proprietorship, a partnership or an S-corporation, and the difference between them can be tens of thousands of dollars a year. Most owners never revisit the default. Natalie C. Papagni, CPA works with owners of single-member and multi-member LLCs in La Jolla, greater San Diego and throughout California. We model each option against your actual numbers, recommend the tax treatment that fits, and then plan the business and your personal return together, year after year, as your income and goals change.
With 15+ years as a CPA specializing in tax, Natalie personally prepares and signs your LLC and personal returns. No handoffs to junior staff. Fixed fees, agreed in advance.
Entity & Tax Election Decisions We Model
The right structure depends on your income, your plans for the business, and how it fits with everything else on your return. We model the options before you decide.
-
Default treatment versus an S-corporation election
-
Single-member versus multi-member structure
-
Reasonable compensation, if an S-corporation election is made
-
Partnership allocations, guaranteed payments and distributions
-
Professional corporation requirements for licensed professionals
-
Holding company and multi-entity structures
-
Separating operating businesses from real estate
-
California, out-of-state and multi-state registration
When an S-Corporation Election Pays
For many LLC owners earning around $120,000 or more in net income, an S-corporation election opens planning opportunities that default treatment doesn't.
-
Payroll tax savings on distributions above a reasonable salary
-
The California PTET election, which converts state tax into a federal deduction
-
Layered retirement plans funded through W-2 wages
-
QBI deduction planning
-
Accountable plan reimbursements, free of payroll tax
-
Clean shareholder basis and distribution planning
How We Work with LLCs
New LLCs
Our post-formation set-up package starts once your LLC is formed. We compare default tax treatment (a disregarded entity for single-member LLCs, a partnership for multi-member LLCs) with an S-corporation election, recommend the right fit, and set up your books, filings and planning from the start.
Existing LLCs
Integrated multi-year planning for the business and its owners, quarterly tax management and estimated payments, business and multi-state returns prepared alongside the owners' personal returns, and review and correction of returns filed by a prior preparer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should my LLC elect to be taxed as an S-corporation?
It depends on your net income and your plans. Single-member and multi-member LLCs pay self-employment tax on the owners' share of profits. With an S-corporation election, owners pay themselves a reasonable salary and can take the remaining profits as distributions free of payroll tax. At around $120,000 or more of net income, the savings often outweigh the added payroll and compliance costs, and the election also opens the California PTET election and retirement plans funded through salary. We model both options with your numbers before recommending one.
What's the difference between an LLC and an S-corporation?
An LLC is a legal entity formed under state law. An S-corporation is a federal tax election. An LLC can keep its default tax treatment or elect to be taxed as an S-corporation while keeping the same legal structure. The question isn't LLC or S-corporation, but how your LLC should be taxed.
How is a single-member LLC taxed in California?
Federally, a single-member LLC is disregarded, and its income is reported on the owner's personal return. California still treats it as a separate entity: it files its own return each year, pays the $800 annual tax and pays an additional LLC fee once its California gross receipts reach $250,000. A disregarded single-member LLC also cannot make the California PTET election. An S-corporation election changes all three.
How is a multi-member LLC taxed, and can members be on payroll?
By default, a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership. The LLC files its own return, and each member reports a share of the income whether or not it is distributed. Members cannot be W-2 employees of their own partnership; payments for their work are guaranteed payments, which, along with most active members' share of profits, are subject to self-employment tax. Putting members on payroll is a common error that creates incorrect returns for both the LLC and its members.
What does a California LLC owe each year?
Every LLC registered or doing business in California owes the $800 annual tax by the 15th day of the fourth month of its tax year, April 15 for calendar-year LLCs. LLCs with California gross receipts of $250,000 or more also owe an LLC fee that rises with receipts, with an estimated payment due by the 15th day of the sixth month. Both apply whether or not the LLC is profitable.
Does a series LLC reduce California fees?
No. California treats each series of a series LLC as a separate LLC, so each series that does business in California files its own return and pays its own $800 annual tax and any LLC fee. Owners holding several rental properties often find that separate LLCs, or a single LLC with adequate insurance, cost the same or less and are simpler to administer.
Should I form my LLC in Delaware, Nevada or Wyoming?
Usually not, if you live in or do business in California. An out-of-state LLC doing business in California must still register here, pay California's $800 annual tax and LLC fee and file a California return, so you pay fees in two states without a California tax benefit. Out-of-state formation can make sense in specific situations, such as investor requirements or some holding structures, so it's worth reviewing before you form.
Can a physician, CPA or other licensed professional use an LLC?
In California, generally not for the licensed practice itself. California does not allow LLCs to provide professional services that require a state license, such as medicine, accounting and law. Licensed professionals typically practice through a professional corporation, which can then elect S-corporation status. An LLC can still be useful for related activities that don't require a license, such as holding real estate.
What should an LLC operating agreement cover for tax purposes?
Beyond ownership and management, the agreement should address how profits, losses and distributions are allocated, whether the LLC makes tax distributions so members can pay tax on income they haven't received, how capital accounts are kept, and who serves as the partnership representative, the person who speaks for the LLC and binds every member in an IRS audit. It should also cover buyouts and transfers. An agreement written without these terms often produces disputes and tax results no one intended.
What happens for tax purposes when a member joins or leaves my LLC?
A new member's contribution of cash or property is generally tax-free, but contributions of services for an ownership interest can be taxable, and the operating agreement must reflect the new allocations. When a member leaves, the buyout may be treated as a sale of the interest or as a redemption by the LLC, with different results for both sides, and part of the payment can be ordinary income rather than capital gain. An optional basis adjustment election can also give the buyer or the remaining members a valuable step-up. These are planned before the transaction closes.
How do I convert my LLC to an S-corporation?
The LLC files an election to be taxed as a corporation and as an S-corporation, generally within two months and 15 days of the date it should take effect, and late-election relief is available in many cases. A multi-member LLC is treated as transferring its assets to a new corporation, which can trigger tax if liabilities exceed the members' basis. The operating agreement must be amended so distributions follow ownership, payroll is set up for working owners, and the LLC files its final partnership returns. Each step is mapped before the effective date.
How do multi-state LLCs taxed as partnerships create tax exposure?
When an LLC has employees, property or sales in other states, it may owe tax or fees there and must apportion its income among them. Members can then face nonresident filing requirements, state withholding and composite return options, and each state's elective entity tax rules differ. Coordinated planning for the LLC and its members avoids double taxation and captures credits for taxes paid to other states.
Why are losses from LLCs taxed as partnerships often limited or disallowed?
A loss must clear several tests before you can deduct it: your basis in the LLC, the at-risk rules, the passive activity rules and the excess business loss limit. Losses that fail a test aren't lost; they're suspended and carried forward. Tracking basis and planning around these limits each year determines when those losses actually reduce your tax.

